Moral and ethical limits of genetic modification philosophy essay

More Essay Examples on Genetics Rubric There are several reasons which parents cite to justify their desire to undergo the procedure. These include the age of the mother, having a child who has a genetic disease, a chromosomal abnormality in either parent, or simply enhanced risk. These are all valid reasons for wanting to avail of prenatal genetic testing.

Moral and ethical limits of genetic modification philosophy essay

International Regulation of Genetic Engineering: An avid debater and scientist, Soo Hyun hopes to engage in cross-cultural dialogue on science and technology's far-reaching impact on modern society.

Otherwise, Soo Hyun can be spotted shooting photos on her 35mm Pentax and trying new tricks on her skateboard albeit not always successful. In your opinion, what is the greatest ethical challenge facing the world today? In an age dominated by competitive materialism, we have designer shoes, designer handbags, and designer faces.

South Korea, my native country, accounts for nearly one-fourth of the global market for plastic surgery, and advertisements of cosmetic surgery litter the walls of subway stations, shopping districts, and even Incheon airport. However, remaking ourselves as adults is one thing.

Are we really ready for designer babies? Inthe United States spent a whopping million dollars on genetic research alone. Scientific advancements have dominated much of the 21st century, making it impossible to ignore the ethical implications of advancing genetic procedures. Though a multitude of ethical debates arise regarding the genetic technologies themselves, given how much the technology has already advanced, it is most practical to consider regulatory aspects of such advancements and their societal ramifications.

Inevitably, without proper regulations, genetic engineering will result in dire new forms of societal discrimination. In order to establish a regulatory framework for genetic technologies, a multitude of ethical dilemmas must be resolved through international cooperation.

The first meeting in the United States for developing a regulatory framework for genetic modification was held in at the Asilomar Conferencewhich outlined voluntary guidelines for the emerging recombinant DNA technology.

Shortly after, a slew of genetic advancements came about: Inscientists successfully cloned Dolly the Sheep from an adult cell through a process of nuclear transfer.

Soo Hyun Kim, Second Prize, High School Category, Essay Contest 2017

Just last year, the world's first three-parent-baby was born through the controversial mitochondrial replacement therapy, in which the nucleus from an egg with defective mitochondria is replaced with a healthy donor egg, which is then fertilized by sperm.

Along the way, fears of "Frankenbabies" and ill-advised human cloning abounded, as individuals wondered how such futuristic technologies would manifest themselves down the road.

Economic Natural Selection A predominant fear that many hold is the likely possibility that genetic technologies would become available exclusively for the rich.

Healthcare disparity between the rich and the poor is already tangible when considering that life expectancies vary by as much as 20 years between affluent and poor areas within the U. Since medicine in principle should work towards achieving a betterment of health for all, the challenge lies in developing a regulatory framework that would expand availability to all socioeconomic class without exclusively benefiting the wealthy and powerful.

Moral and ethical limits of genetic modification philosophy essay

Moreover, as developed nations generally enjoy a greater level of medical advancement and overall wealth, ethical consideration must be given to how continued advancement of these genetic procedures have the potential to accelerate global health inequality, further aggravating geopolitical power imbalances.

Global health inequality is already at a critical state; according to the World Health Organization, the risk of a child dying before turning one was over six times higher in Africa than in Europe.

Similar statistics apply for European countries where universal healthcare is guaranteed. The plurality of global healthcare structures pose a hindrance for drafting an internationally consented set of regulations, as the availability of such technologies, and hence the social ramifications, would vary for each nation.

A New Era of Eugenics? Accordingly, many find alarming the possibility that genetic engineering could open doors for a new form of societal imbalance and discrimination against the unmodified. This fear is historically justified; we have witnessed the genocidal effects of Eugenics not only in countries abroad such as Japan, Sweden, and Nazi Germany but even in our own backyard.


Peaking in the s to 30s, the Eugenics movement in the United States promoted an elimination of "negative" traits on the basis of race, disability, promiscuity, and criminality.

A frightening parallel arises with genetic engineering. When the inherent biology of an individual can be altered, concerns arise as to whether certain people's lives can be engineered to be more valuable than others. A baby born on the autism spectrum is no less of a human being than a baby born without such a disorder.

If genetic engineering were to have no limits, individuals without modifications may come to bear the burden of hearing society announce that their "undesirable traits" diminish their worth. Yet, in the process of creating a regulatory framework to address these issues, another major ethical obstacle emerges:GENE THERAPY: ETHICAL AND SOCIAL ISSUES Robert M.

Sade, M.D. and George Khushf, Ph.D. respectively. Modification of genetic DNA leads to changes in both the structure and amounts of protein it ultimately produces. In recent years, a variety of techniques have been developed to identify genes associated Trials to define limits .

Department of Philosophy and Program in Applied Ethics Fairfield University Curtis R.

On Prenatal Genetic Testing: Ethical and Moral Issues Essay Example | Graduateway

Naser is a medical ethicist who specializes in biomedical research involving human subjects. This section is on the hypothetical genetic modification of human individuals through genetic engineering and the actual modification of the gene pool through (eugenic or disgenic) genetic selection.

The ethics of gene-therapy and genetic selection is especially complex. Implications of Genetic Modification and Genetic Selection (Washington DC: Georgetown University Press, , in press).

Annotating the Moral Map of Enhancement: Gene Doping, the Limits of Medicine and the Spirit of Sport Eric T. Juengst I.

RehovotIsrael; E-mail:
The Ethics of Human Genetic Enhancement: Extending the Public Policy Debate.
These concepts have, on the one hand, a theoretical origin and are, on the other hand, based on the moral beliefs of people not directly involved in the genetic modification of animals.

Introduction philosophy of sport, which have different moral lessons for . Is genetic engineering ethically right? Ethics are standards of right and wrong, good and bad.

Ethics is the system of moral principles. The Fair Use Policy; Help Centre; Is Genetic Engineering Ethically Right Philosophy Essay.

Moral and ethical limits of genetic modification philosophy essay

Print Reference this Another type of genetic engineering is genetic modification of embryo also known as. Social and Ethical Implications of Biotechnology Essay Words 4 Pages The term Gene Technology is interrelated and can be understood by the expression of genes by taking the natural genetic variations, modifying genes and transferring genes are the advantages to the new hosts.

The Ethics of Animal Experimentation - HOPES Huntington's Disease Information